English 569: Digital Media and English Studies
Visual Rhetoric and Documentary Form
Modes of Documentary Representation

 

Expository Mode (Jen, Katie, Nathan, Jennifer) (rev. 4.14.2004)

  • Voice-of-God commentary; the filmmaker is voice of authority
  • Addresses the viewers directly, telling them what to think
  • Offered as "Truth," the documentary presents "the facts," emphasizing the impression of objectivity and well-substantiated judgment
  • Raises ethical issues
  • Builds a sense of dramatic involvement around the need for a solution
  • Uses a poetic perspective, romanticizing the subject, to encourage the empathy from the viewer
  • The voice of authority resides with the text itself; witnesses, testimony, etc. serve to contribute evidence and support to the filmmaker's argument
  • Nonsynchronous sound
  • Viewers expect logical cause-effect linkage between events and sequences
  • Viewer expects text to take shape around the solution to a problem
  • Transparency; masks the work of production

Observational Mode (Chuck, Dawn, Lyndsay, Erin ) (rev. 4.15.2004)

  • Stresses the nonintervention of the filmmaker
  • Films rely on editing and repetitive images to enhance the impression of real or lived time
  • Do not have commentary, direct addressing of subjects, or outside interventions
  • Centered around the everyday, the personal, the intimate
  • Used as an ethnographic tool - captures more of what is happening
  • Conveys the sense of unmediated access to the world, what an observer would really experience
  • Emphasizes the ethical questions of how much the filmmaker canintrude and how well he/she can stay hidden
  • Uses more mobile, synchronous equipment, and has a fixed camera position

Interactive Mode (Lindy, Ben, Jamie L., Chasity)

  • Interactive documentary stresses images of testimony or verbal exchange and images of demonstration (images that demonstrate the validity, or possibility, the doubtfulness, of what the witness state.)
  • Interaction often revolves around the form known as the interview.
  • The interactive text takes many forms but all draw their social actors into direct encounter with the filmmaker.
  • The interactive mode helped establish the genre of historical reconstruction based on oral history or witness testimony and archival rather than on a voice-over commentary.
  • A characteristic of the interactive mode is an assembly of discreet pieces creating a film routed in individual perspective or personal recollection.
  • A feature of the interactive mode is the masked interview is when the filmmaker is both off screen and unheard.
  • The scenes in an interactive mode tend to focus not only on the "talking head" but also the surrounding set.

Reflexive Mode (Ray, Jamie G., Kathy, Mike)

  • Example: Documentary about making a documentary
  • Reflexive texts are self-conscious not only about form and style but also about strategy structure, conventions, expectations and effects.
  • Gives emphasis to the encounter between filmmaker and viewer rather than filmmaker and subject.
  • Focus of text goes from the realism of historical reference to the properties of the text itself.
  • Reflexivity focuses on problems, that is what draws attention
  • It is an ethical dilemma of how to represent people in two distinct ways.
  • Posed as an issue the text itself may address specifically
  • Also poses text as an issue for the viewer by emphasizing the degree to which people, or social actors, appear before us as signifiers, as functions of the text itself
  • Rarely reflects on ethical issues as a primary concern.
  • Remove excursions of habit
  • Stylistic Reflexivity, Deconstructive Reflexivity, Interactivity, Irony, Parody and Satire.